8 Comments
Willard said...
An impossible task? Maybe. But, this is an awful series of choices. I read enough to see that the author was born AFTER the Beatles broke up, which means he lacks a certain perspective. It shows in his list.
Anonymous said...
Oooooh that comment was a little harsh Willard, this was a personal list, from Jbev's own perspective. That does mean that this list has no meaning or importance to any other person, but it was important to him. I was born before the Beatles were formed, but if I were to draw up my own list, it would be just as relevant as Jbev's and that is why I have no intention of doing one. RegardsMarcel Marceau
A BEATLES' HARD-DIE'S SITE said...
Say what you want, but the fact is that everytime we try to propose this list it never slips away in silence... and this must be recognized to JBev's bravery...
Anonymous said...
Just because there's nothing you can do that can't be done, doesn't mean you have to do it !MM
Anonymous said...
I think this list is meaningless. I can come up with my own list, but who even cares? Fact is, everybody has their own tastes and opinions. In this case, I think it would've been preferable had the author kept his opinions and critiques to himself... Just my opinion.
A BEATLES' HARD-DIE'S SITE said...
In OOO... if this list is meaningless, why so many people feels the need to say it is?
Anonymous said...
Because they are right ?MM
A BEATLES' HARD-DIE'S SITE said...
DO YOU REALLY THINK SOMEONE HERE IS RIGHT AND SOMEONE IS WRONG? ARE WE IN A COURT? IS THIS WHAT WE ARE DOING HERE SINCE ONE YEAR? DECIDING WHAT IS RIGHT AND WHAT IS WRONG? OOH, WHAT A FOOL WE HAVE BEEN IN WORKING SO HARD... SEE YOU IN ONE MONTH AS A MINIMUM... AND TAKE YOUR TIME TO THINK...
3 comments:
Yep. you are right, this list is the only thing posted on your great site the has drawn adverse comments.
Still, people are people and the Beatles still have the power to create strong feelings which is a testement to how great they were.
I guess you can't always expect to have people like everything you post, but don't take it to heart, none of the comments appear to be aimed at you, I'm sure that my list and your list would be different but so what ! It doesn't change the fact that it is all great music whatever order you put it in. Have a nice break, see you soon
Mal
Hey, look I'm sorry if I pissed you off, my comments were not a critical comment on you or your blog. as I do feel bad, please accept my apology
MM
Gee, passions are certainly running high around here. I guess I'll refrain from submitting my own list, which would have "Revolution 9", "The Inner Light", "You Know My Name (Look Up The Number)", and "Tell Me Why" all in my top 10 and "Something" down in the hundreds somewhere. ;-)
Lighten up, people. The Beatles' music will never die, and we all experience it in our own way. And you know you should be glad.
Post a Comment